Best loyalty program for a small business: how to choose with six questions
The best loyalty program for a small business is the one customers get without explaining. Choose between a stamp card, points, levels, or membership with six questions.
The best loyalty program for a small business is the one your customer understands without any explanation and uses without any effort. Most of the time that is a stamp card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet: one line, no app, a reward you can reach within a few months. Points, levels, or a membership only suit certain kinds of shops.
In short
- There is no single best loyalty program in general; it depends on how often your customer comes in and how much they spend.
- For most hairdressers, cafes, salons, and shops, a simple stamp card beats a complicated points system.
- A card in your customer's wallet gets used more than a card in a separate app or on paper.
What makes the best loyalty program for a small business?
Big chains build programs with apps, points, partners, and personal offers. That works for them, because they have millions of customers and a marketing team. A small business needs something else: a program that takes two seconds at the counter and that the customer remembers without you having to explain it.
Why bother? Research by Frederick Reichheld of Bain & Company, discussed in Harvard Business Review, shows that a 5 percent increase in customer retention can raise profit by 25 to 95 percent. A regular customer costs you no more advertising, often spends more, and brings people along.
The best loyalty program for a small business therefore meets five requirements:
- The rule fits in one sentence. "Ten coffees, the eleventh is free." If you need a second sentence, it is too complicated.
- The customer sees their progress. A card sitting in a drawer somewhere motivates no one.
- The reward is within reach. Within three to six months, or the customer forgets they are collecting.
- It costs you and your team almost no time. Stamping should be faster than ringing up the sale.
- You can reach the customer later. A message to someone who has not been in for a while is often worth more than the reward itself.
The four types side by side
Almost every loyalty program is one of four types. So the question "what is the best loyalty program" is really the question of which of these four fits your shop.
| Type | How it works | Suits | Watch out for | |---|---|---|---| | Stamp card | One stamp per visit or purchase, reward after a fixed number | Hairdresser, cafe, bakery, nail salon, car wash | Less suited if spend per visit varies a lot | | Points card | Points per euro, redeem for a reward | Shop, jeweller, garage, beauty salon with pricey treatments | The customer has to do the maths; explain clearly what a point is worth | | Levels | Bronze, silver, gold with fixed perks per level | Shops with a small group of very loyal customers | Only works when the difference between levels is noticeable | | Membership | A fixed amount per month for a fixed service | Tanning studio, wellness, barbershop with a monthly cut, car wash | You have to actually deliver the service every month |
Coupons and vouchers are not in the table, because they are not a type on their own. They are an extra layer: a birthday voucher, a discount for a returning customer, a gift on sign-up. You can see an overview of all the types with examples at card types.
Six questions to choose the best loyalty program
You do not need to write a marketing plan. Answer these six questions and the choice makes itself.
- How often does an average customer come in? Weekly or more: a stamp card with eight to ten stamps. Every four to eight weeks: a stamp card with five to eight stamps. A few times a year: points or levels.
- How much does a customer spend each time? For example under 30 pounds: stamps. Between 30 and 200 pounds: stamps or points. Above that: points, so a big purchase counts for more.
- Is the service the same every time? Yes, and the customer comes every month? Then a membership is worth considering. No? Then stick with stamps or points.
- Who does the stamping? If you work alone, it barely matters. If you work with a team, choose a system where each member has their own login and where you can see who stamped what.
- Do you want to message customers later? A paper card cannot do that. A digital card with push messages can: a reminder, a birthday voucher, or a nudge when the card is nearly full.
- How much time do you want to put in? Answer honestly. A program that needs attention every week dies in the busy months. Choose something that keeps running even if you do not look at it for a month.
If you are still unsure after these six questions, start with a stamp card. Customers get it straight away, and you can add points, levels, or a membership later. How to set that up step by step is covered in setting up a loyalty program.
App, wallet, or paper: where does the card live?
The type is half the choice. The other half is where the card lives, because a card the customer does not have with them does not get used.
Paper is cheap and quick. You know the downside: cards get lost, stay at home in a drawer, or get coloured in with someone's own stamp. You also do not know who your customers are, so you cannot send anyone anything.
Your own app offers plenty of options, but it asks the customer to download something, make an account, and remember a password. For a hairdresser or bakery, that is a big ask for a free cut or a free loaf.
A card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet sits in between. Both wallets support loyalty cards, as Apple's and Google's help pages show. The customer scans a QR code, taps add, and the card sits next to their bank card. No app, no account.
There is one more reason to make progress visible. In a field study by Nunes and Drèze at a car wash, 34 percent of customers completed a ten-stamp card when it already had two stamps on it. With an eight-space card that started empty, it was 19 percent, even though both groups needed the same number of washes. People finish what they have already started, as long as they can see it.
What to look for in a provider
If you go digital, you need a provider. There are several, each with its own approach. A few examples, described plainly:
- Piggy is a broad loyalty platform with its own app, gift cards, email campaigns, and links to till and webshop systems. Strong if you want to connect a lot.
- Spari works with its own customer app and a scanner app for the shop, and has a free basic plan for collecting points.
- Stempely puts stamp cards in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet and lets customers stamp via a QR code or NFC.
- Loyalzoo supplies loyalty cards and gift cards in your own branding, with an app for the customer.
You can find a fuller comparison in the article on digital stamp card providers. Whichever you choose, check these points:
- Does the customer have to download an app? If so, expect fewer sign-ups.
- How fast is stamping? Have them show you. If it takes longer than ringing up the sale, it falls apart when you are busy.
- Can staff log in separately? And can you see who gave which stamp? With a team, that is the only way to prevent stamps being given away.
- Can you send messages, and automatically too? Think of a birthday or a customer who has not been in for weeks.
- Who owns the customer data? You should be able to view, export, and delete it. Also ask about the data processing agreement.
- What does it really cost? Look at the total per year, including the value of the rewards. That is what the article what a loyalty program costs covers.
At the salons I talk to, I keep seeing the same thing: the shop that chooses on the number of features uses two of them after three months. The shop that chooses on ease at the counter is still using it.
Beepify is one of those providers, so read this with that in mind. With us, a shop makes a stamp card, points card, level card, membership, or coupon in about five minutes, and it sits in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet. Staff stamp with their own login code, every stamp goes into a log, and suspicious stamping patterns are flagged to the owner. What it costs is on the pricing page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best loyalty program?
For a small business, the best loyalty program is the one the customer understands without any explanation and uses without any effort. Most of the time that is a stamp card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet: one line, no app, a reward within reach in three to six months. Points, levels, or a membership are better if your customer spends a lot or takes the same service every month.
What types of loyalty program are there?
With small businesses you see four types. The stamp card gives a stamp per visit. The points system gives points per euro. Levels reward loyal customers with fixed perks, like bronze, silver, and gold. The membership is a fixed amount per month for a fixed service. Coupons and vouchers are an add-on that suits all four.
Is a loyalty program with its own app better than a wallet card?
For most small businesses, no. Every download is a hurdle: some customers drop off the moment you ask them to install an app. A card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet is already ready to go on nearly every phone. Your own app mainly makes sense for chains with a webshop, pre-ordering, or a large range.
What are some nice ways to attract customers?
Offers that give something straight away work best. Think of a welcome stamp on sign-up, double stamps on quiet days, a birthday voucher, or a message with a small reward for customers who have not been in for a while. Link every offer to the card, so you can also see who responds to it.
How quickly is a loyalty program ready?
A digital stamp card is ready within an hour with most providers, often in a few minutes. You choose the type, the reward, and the number of stamps, add your logo, and print a QR code for the counter. Most of the work is in choosing the reward, not in the tech.
How many stamps does the best loyalty program have?
Between six and ten, depending on how often your customer comes in. A coffee shop with daily customers can ask for ten stamps. A hairdresser where people come every six weeks is better off with six to eight. Rule of thumb: the customer should be able to reach the reward within three to six months, or they drop off.
Try it yourself?
Answer the six questions and build your card for free at beepify.app/start. You see it straight away, just as your customer gets it in their wallet. After that, you walk through how stamping and messages work in a 15-minute demo with someone from Beepify. Read more about building a program at setting up a loyalty program.
Източници
Често задавани въпроси
What is the best loyalty program?
For a small business, the best loyalty program is the one the customer understands without any explanation and uses without any effort. Most of the time that is a stamp card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet: one line, no app, a reward within reach in three to six months. Points, levels, or a membership are better if your customer spends a lot or takes the same service every month.
What types of loyalty program are there?
With small businesses you see four types. The stamp card gives a stamp per visit. The points system gives points per euro. Levels reward loyal customers with fixed perks, like bronze, silver, and gold. The membership is a fixed amount per month for a fixed service. Coupons and vouchers are an add-on that suits all four.
Is a loyalty program with its own app better than a wallet card?
For most small businesses, no. Every download is a hurdle: some customers drop off the moment you ask them to install an app. A card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet is already ready to go on nearly every phone. Your own app mainly makes sense for chains with a webshop, pre-ordering, or a large range.
What are some nice ways to attract customers?
Offers that give something straight away work best. Think of a welcome stamp on sign-up, double stamps on quiet days, a birthday voucher, or a message with a small reward for customers who have not been in for a while. Link every offer to the card, so you can also see who responds to it.
How quickly is a loyalty program ready?
A digital stamp card is ready within an hour with most providers, often in a few minutes. You choose the type, the reward, and the number of stamps, add your logo, and print a QR code for the counter. Most of the work is in choosing the reward, not in the tech.
How many stamps does the best loyalty program have?
Between six and ten, depending on how often your customer comes in. A coffee shop with daily customers can ask for ten stamps. A hairdresser where people come every six weeks is better off with six to eight. Rule of thumb: the customer should be able to reach the reward within three to six months, or they drop off.
Искате ли да опитате сами?
Създайте своя дигитална карта с печати за 5 минути. Без приложение, с отказ всеки месец.
Изберете своя бранш и вижте как работиСвързани статии
Stocard Replacement: What the End of Stocard Means for Your Loyalty Card
Stocard shut down and Klarna is the replacement, but not everyone moved. Here is why your own wallet pass beats a borrowed app, and how to set one up.
9 min четене
Pedicure client retention: how clients come back every 6 to 8 weeks on their own
Pedicure client retention comes down to rhythm. See how clients return every six to eight weeks with simple booking habits, timely reminders, and small rewards.
9 min четене
Make a free punch card: on paper with Word or Canva, or digital in the wallet
Make a free punch card in two ways: on paper in Word or Canva, or digital in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet. See what belongs on it and which fits your shop.
9 min четене